New York Mutuals 1876 Roster

Wins: 21 | Losses: 35 | Rank in 1876: 6

George Bechtel

Eddie Booth

Bill Craver

George Fair

Davy Force

Jimmy Hallinan

John Hatfield

John Hayes

George Heubel

Nat Hicks

Jim Holdsworth

Terry Larkin

John Maloney

Bobby Mathews

John McGuinness

Al Nichols

Nealy Phelps

George Seward

Jim Shanley

Joe Start

Fred Treacey

Pete Treacey

Bob Valentine

Billy West